Before You Expose Them: The Biblical Way to Confront Sin and Handle Conflict
Christian Living
Before You Expose Them
The Biblical Way to Confront Sin and Handle Conflict
Scripture gives believers principles for addressing wrongdoing, conflict, accusations, and persistent sin. The goal should not be humiliation, revenge, gossip, or gathering an audience. Biblical correction seeks truth, accountability, repentance, protection, and restoration.
Written by Avery Raquel
Founder of Avery Raquel Ministries and Disciples of Christ Ministries. This Bible-based teaching examines Matthew 18, private confrontation, witnesses, church involvement, restoration, public correction, accusations, gossip, leadership accountability, and important exceptions involving abuse, danger, or criminal conduct.
Should Christians Immediately Expose Someone Who Has Done Wrong?
Social media has made public exposure incredibly easy.
Someone offends you.
Someone sins.
Someone says something wrong.
Someone disappoints you.
And within minutes, hundreds or thousands of people can be invited into a conflict that originally involved only two people.
Sometimes public accountability is necessary.
Scripture itself contains examples of public rebuke and public exposure of serious wrongdoing.
But Scripture also gives believers a process for handling many conflicts before immediately making them public.
Jesus specifically taught His disciples how to deal with a brother who had trespassed.
That teaching is found in Matthew 18:15–17.
Biblical correction should begin with a desire for truth and restoration, not a desire to embarrass somebody before an audience.
Jesus Gave a Process in Matthew 18
“Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.
And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.”
Matthew 18:15–17 KJV
Notice the progression.
Jesus does not begin with:
“Tell everybody.”
He begins with:
“Go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone.”
1. First, Go to the Person Privately
“...go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone...”
Matthew 18:15 KJV
This first step is private.
If a fellow believer has wronged you, Scripture encourages direct communication rather than immediately involving unnecessary people.
Go to the person.
Explain the concern.
Give them an opportunity to respond.
There may be information you do not know.
There may have been a misunderstanding.
The person may immediately acknowledge what happened and repent.
If the matter can be resolved privately, there may be no biblical reason to turn it into a public spectacle.
2. The Goal Is to Gain Your Brother, Not Destroy Them
Jesus explains the desired outcome:
“...if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.”
Matthew 18:15 KJV
That sentence reveals the spirit of the process.
The goal is restoration.
Not humiliation.
Not revenge.
Not proving to social media that you were right.
Not gathering people who already dislike the person.
The desired result is repentance, truth, peace, and restoration where restoration is possible and appropriate.
3. Listen Before Deciding You Know the Entire Story
“He that answereth a matter before he heareth it, it is folly and shame unto him.”
Proverbs 18:13 KJV
Hearing one person's version of a conflict does not automatically mean you know everything that happened.
Proverbs also says:
“He that is first in his own cause seemeth just; but his neighbour cometh and searcheth him.”
Proverbs 18:17 KJV
In other words, the first story you hear may sound completely convincing until additional information is presented.
Biblical justice requires patience with facts.
4. Do Not Turn a Private Conflict Into Gossip
There is a difference between seeking wise counsel and recruiting an audience.
You may sometimes need counsel from a mature believer, pastor, elder, counselor, or appropriate professional.
But telling twenty people about a conflict simply because you are angry is something entirely different.
“A talebearer revealeth secrets: but he that is of a faithful spirit concealeth the matter.”
Proverbs 11:13 KJV
Not every conflict needs spectators.
5. If They Refuse to Listen, Bring One or Two Others
“But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.”
Matthew 18:16 KJV
Jesus then expands the circle.
But notice that He still does not immediately jump from private correction to worldwide public exposure.
One or two others are brought into the situation.
6. Choose Mature People, Not People You Know Will Automatically Take Your Side
The purpose of involving others should not be to intimidate the accused person.
Do not choose people simply because they already dislike the person.
Choose trustworthy and spiritually mature people who are willing to hear carefully, seek truth, and correct either party if necessary.
Sometimes the person bringing the complaint may also need correction.
Mature mediation requires impartiality.
7. Scripture Takes Witnesses Seriously
The principle of establishing a matter through witnesses appears throughout Scripture.
“...at the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall the matter be established.”
Deuteronomy 19:15 KJV
Jesus draws upon this principle in Matthew 18.
Serious accusations should not be treated carelessly.
Truth matters.
Evidence matters.
Accountability matters.
8. If They Still Refuse Correction, Tell It to the Church
“And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church...”
Matthew 18:17 KJV
The matter becomes more serious when someone refuses private correction and refuses the intervention of additional witnesses.
Jesus then instructs that the matter be brought before the church.
This is church discipline.
It should be handled with biblical order, maturity, truth, and appropriate leadership.
It should not become religious entertainment.
9. Church Discipline Is Not the Same Thing as Social Media Exposure
“Tell it unto the church” does not automatically mean:
“Post it to the entire internet.”
Jesus was describing accountability within the community of believers.
The internet is not your local church.
Your followers are not automatically a biblical disciplinary council.
A comment section is not a substitute for mature spiritual leadership.
There can be circumstances where wrongdoing becomes legitimately public, but Matthew 18 should not be rewritten as an excuse for immediate online exposure.
10. What Happens If They Refuse Even the Church?
“...but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.”
Matthew 18:17 KJV
Persistent refusal to repent changes the nature of fellowship.
The church should not pretend that unrepentant conduct is acceptable simply to avoid uncomfortable confrontation.
Biblical love includes truth.
Grace does not mean eliminating accountability.
11. Restoration Should Be Done in Meekness
“Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.”
Galatians 6:1 KJV
Look at the language Paul uses.
Restore.
Not crush.
Not mock.
Not celebrate their downfall.
And Paul tells the person doing the correcting to examine themselves.
Correction should never become an excuse for spiritual pride.
12. Repentance Should Change What Happens Next
If someone acknowledges their wrongdoing, repents, and seeks to make things right, the purpose of correction is being accomplished.
That does not mean every consequence instantly disappears.
Serious wrongdoing may still require accountability.
Trust may need to be rebuilt.
Leadership responsibilities may need to change.
Legal consequences may still exist.
But repentance should matter.
Christians should not claim to desire repentance and then become angry when someone actually repents because they preferred destruction.
13. Forgiveness Does Not Eliminate Accountability
Forgiveness is biblical.
Accountability is also biblical.
These are not opposites.
Forgiving someone does not require pretending the offense never occurred.
Forgiveness does not necessarily restore a person immediately to the same position of trust.
Where serious misconduct has occurred, wisdom may require boundaries, supervision, restitution, counseling, removal from leadership, or other appropriate consequences.
14. Accusations Against Church Leaders Require Serious Care
Scripture gives specific instructions concerning accusations against elders.
“Against an elder receive not an accusation, but before two or three witnesses.”
1 Timothy 5:19 KJV
This does not mean leaders are above accountability.
It means accusations should be handled seriously rather than carelessly.
Leaders should not be condemned on the basis of unsupported rumor.
At the same time, the following verse shows that leadership does not make someone immune from public correction when established sin persists.
15. Scripture Does Allow Public Rebuke in Appropriate Circumstances
“Them that sin rebuke before all, that others also may fear.”
1 Timothy 5:20 KJV
Therefore, the biblical teaching is not:
“Sin must never be addressed publicly.”
That would also be inaccurate.
There are situations where public wrongdoing requires public accountability.
Especially where leadership, widespread harm, false teaching, or persistent public sin is involved.
The question is not simply:
“Can something ever be exposed publicly?”
The better questions are:
Is the accusation true? Has the matter been established? What does Scripture require in this situation? What is the purpose of making it public?
16. Paul Publicly Corrected Peter
Scripture itself gives an example of public correction.
Paul writes concerning Peter:
“But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.”
Galatians 2:11 KJV
Peter's conduct affected other believers publicly.
Paul addressed the problem directly.
This is important because Matthew 18 should not be used as though every form of correction must always remain private regardless of context.
Scripture contains both private correction and public correction.
Wisdom requires understanding which situation you are dealing with.
17. Matthew 18 Should Be Read in Its Actual Context
Matthew 18:15 begins:
“Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee...”
Matthew 18:15 KJV
Therefore, we should be careful about treating Matthew 18 as though it is a mechanical procedure governing every possible wrongdoing in every possible circumstance.
The passage clearly teaches important principles about confrontation, witnesses, church involvement, and discipline between believers.
But other biblical passages also address leaders, public sin, false teachers, criminal wrongdoing, danger, and other circumstances.
Biblical wisdom requires looking at the whole counsel of Scripture.
18. You Are Not Required to Privately Confront a Dangerous Person Before Seeking Safety
This is an extremely important distinction.
Matthew 18 should never be weaponized against victims of abuse.
A victim of physical violence, sexual abuse, child abuse, serious threats, stalking, coercion, or other dangerous behavior should not be told:
“You cannot tell anybody until you confront the person privately.”
That can place someone in greater danger.
Safety matters.
Serious wrongdoing may need to be reported immediately to appropriate authorities or protective services.
19. Criminal Conduct Is Not Merely a Church Conflict
Some situations go beyond an interpersonal disagreement.
Criminal behavior may require involvement from lawful authorities.
Romans 13 recognizes governing authorities as having a legitimate role in addressing wrongdoing.
“For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain...”
Romans 13:4 KJV
A church should never use internal discipline as a substitute for reporting conduct that must appropriately be addressed by civil authorities.
20. Do Not Hide Serious Sin Under the Name of “Protecting the Church”
Biblical order should never become institutional cover-up.
Protecting the reputation of a ministry is not more important than truth, justice, or the safety of people.
If serious wrongdoing occurred, leaders should not pressure victims into silence simply because public knowledge may embarrass the organization.
God's church is not protected by hiding evil.
God's people are protected by truth, righteousness, wisdom, accountability, and appropriate action.
21. False Accusations Are Also Serious
Protecting victims and taking accusations seriously does not mean every accusation should automatically be treated as proven fact.
Scripture repeatedly values truthful testimony and established facts.
False accusations can destroy reputations, families, ministries, careers, and relationships.
Do not lie about someone because you are angry.
Do not exaggerate.
Do not remove important context intentionally.
Do not present assumptions as confirmed facts.
Truth must govern both accusation and defense.
22. Do Not Confuse a Rumor With Evidence
“Somebody told me” is not always reliable evidence.
Neither is:
- A cropped screenshot without context
- An anonymous social media account
- A viral video someone edited
- Something repeated by many people
- A personal assumption
- A claim from someone who did not witness the event
Popularity does not transform an unverified accusation into truth.
23. Do Not Call Gossip “Discernment”
Christians should exercise discernment.
But discernment is not permission to spread every allegation you hear.
Saying:
“Something in my spirit told me...”
does not automatically establish another person's guilt.
Spiritual language should never be used as a substitute for truth and evidence.
24. Do Not Use “God Told Me” to Avoid Biblical Accountability
Someone may claim:
“God told me to expose them.”
But claims of divine direction should still be tested according to Scripture.
“Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God...”
1 John 4:1 KJV
God does not need us to violate truth in order to defend truth.
25. Public Sin May Require Public Correction
If someone publicly teaches harmful false doctrine, publicly abuses spiritual authority, or commits conduct affecting many people, the response may not remain identical to a private disagreement between two believers.
Public conduct can create a public need for clarification or correction.
However, even then, Christians should remain committed to truth, proportionality, evidence, and godly motives.
Public correction should not become entertainment.
26. Ask Yourself Why You Want to Expose Them
Before making someone's wrongdoing public, examine your motive.
Ask:
- Am I trying to protect someone from genuine harm?
- Am I trying to establish truth?
- Am I seeking legitimate accountability?
- Or am I angry and trying to destroy someone?
- Am I hoping everyone turns against them?
- Am I enjoying their downfall?
- Would I still handle this the same way if nobody applauded me?
Motive does not determine whether facts are true, but motive still matters before God.
27. Do Not Celebrate When Someone Falls
“Rejoice not when thine enemy falleth, and let not thine heart be glad when he stumbleth.”
Proverbs 24:17 KJV
Someone may genuinely need correction.
Someone may genuinely need removal from leadership.
Someone may genuinely need consequences.
But Christians should be cautious about turning another person's downfall into celebration.
28. Correction Without Love Can Become Cruelty
Truth matters.
Love also matters.
Biblical love does not mean ignoring wrongdoing.
But biblical correction should not lose all compassion.
The same Bible that commands believers to confront sin also commands believers to walk in humility, patience, meekness, and love.
29. Church Leaders Should Not Protect Friends From Accountability
Church discipline becomes corrupted when rules apply differently depending upon who the person is.
A close friend should not be protected simply because they are popular.
A major donor should not receive a different standard.
A well-known preacher should not become untouchable.
A leader's spouse or family member should not automatically be shielded.
Biblical justice should not depend upon status.
30. Correction Should Always Leave Room for Genuine Repentance
Christianity is a Gospel of repentance and redemption.
Therefore, when genuine repentance occurs, the church should know how to recognize it.
This does not mean restoring every person to every former position.
Some consequences may remain.
Some positions require particular qualifications.
Some relationships may require long-term boundaries.
But believers should never become so committed to someone's permanent destruction that repentance becomes meaningless.
The Matthew 18 Process at a Glance
Go directly to the person and address the offense between the two of you.
If the person refuses to listen, involve one or two mature people so that the matter can be properly heard and established.
If the person continues refusing correction, bring the matter into appropriate church accountability.
Continued refusal even after church correction affects fellowship and should not simply be ignored.
Important: When You Should Not Treat Matthew 18 as a Mandatory Private Confrontation
Immediate private confrontation may be unsafe or inappropriate where there is:
- Physical violence
- Child abuse
- Sexual abuse or assault
- Serious threats
- Stalking
- Coercion
- Immediate danger
- Criminal conduct requiring reporting
- Serious exploitation
- Situations where confronting the person could place someone at greater risk
In those circumstances, seek safety and involve appropriate authorities, protective services, professionals, trusted leadership, or emergency assistance as needed.
Questions to Ask Before Publicly Exposing Someone
- Do I actually know that the accusation is true?
- Have I heard more than one side where appropriate?
- Is this a private disagreement or a matter affecting many people?
- Have I spoken privately with the person where Matthew 18 appropriately applies?
- Have mature witnesses or church leaders been appropriately involved?
- Is someone currently in danger?
- Is this potentially criminal conduct that should be reported?
- Am I seeking restoration, accountability, protection, or revenge?
- Am I presenting facts accurately?
- Am I spreading information that I cannot verify?
- Would public disclosure protect others from genuine harm?
- Could this matter be resolved responsibly without unnecessary public humiliation?
- Am I handling this in a way that I can defend biblically before God?
Frequently Asked Questions About Biblical Correction
What does Matthew 18 say to do when another Christian sins against you?
Matthew 18:15–17 begins with private confrontation. If the person refuses to listen, one or two others are brought in. If the person still refuses correction, the matter is brought before the church.
Should Christians expose people publicly?
Not every offense should be immediately exposed publicly. Scripture includes principles of private correction and restoration, but it also includes public rebuke when circumstances warrant it. The nature of the offense, evidence, danger, leadership responsibility, public impact, and biblical context should all be considered.
Does Matthew 18 mean I must confront an abuser privately before reporting them?
No. Matthew 18 should not be used to force victims into unsafe private confrontations. Abuse, serious threats, criminal behavior, or immediate danger may require authorities, protective services, professional help, or emergency assistance.
Can church leaders be publicly rebuked?
Scripture requires accusations against elders to be handled seriously and not received carelessly. First Timothy 5:19 refers to two or three witnesses, while verse 20 states that those who persist in sin may be rebuked before all.
Is church discipline supposed to embarrass people?
The biblical goal is correction and restoration, not entertainment or humiliation. Galatians 6:1 instructs spiritual believers to restore a person overtaken in a fault in a spirit of meekness.
What if the person refuses to repent?
Matthew 18 teaches progressively stronger accountability when a believer refuses correction. Persistent refusal eventually affects fellowship with the church.
Can public sin be corrected publicly?
Yes, Scripture contains examples of public correction, including Paul's confrontation with Peter in Galatians 2 and Paul's instruction regarding persistent sin among elders in 1 Timothy 5. Public correction, however, should still be based upon truth and appropriate biblical grounds.
Does forgiveness mean there should be no consequences?
No. Forgiveness does not eliminate every consequence. Trust may need to be rebuilt, restitution may be appropriate, leadership responsibilities may change, and criminal wrongdoing may still carry legal consequences.
The Central Lesson
Do not confuse biblical correction with public humiliation.
Go privately when Scripture calls for private correction. Establish the truth. Involve mature witnesses when necessary. Bring persistent sin into proper church accountability. Protect people who are in danger. Report serious wrongdoing appropriately. And let restoration, truth, justice, and obedience to God guide the process.
Final Thoughts: Correct Biblically Before You Expose Emotionally
Christians should not become people who eagerly search for someone to destroy.
Neither should Christians become people who ignore serious sin because confrontation makes them uncomfortable.
Scripture gives us a better way.
Speak truth.
Establish facts.
Seek restoration.
Use witnesses appropriately.
Involve church leadership when necessary.
Hold leaders accountable.
Protect victims.
Report serious wrongdoing when appropriate.
Refuse gossip.
Refuse false accusations.
Refuse cover-ups.
Refuse revenge disguised as righteousness.
And when genuine repentance occurs, remember that the Gospel is also about restoration.
Before you put somebody on blast, make sure you are not skipping the biblical principles God gave us for truth, correction, accountability, restoration, and justice.
Prayer for Wisdom in Handling Conflict
Father, in the name of Jesus Christ, give me wisdom when dealing with conflict, offense, accusations, and wrongdoing.
Help me respond according to Your Word rather than according to anger, pride, embarrassment, or revenge.
Give me courage to address problems when they need to be addressed.
Give me humility to listen when I may not have the entire story.
Keep me from spreading gossip, rumors, exaggerations, and false accusations.
Help me value truth above popularity.
Where private correction is appropriate, give me wisdom to speak directly and respectfully.
Where witnesses or church leadership are needed, lead me to mature and trustworthy people.
Where serious wrongdoing has occurred, give me courage to seek appropriate accountability and protection.
Protect victims from being silenced in the name of religion.
Protect the innocent from false accusation.
Protect Your church from leaders who misuse authority.
Help those who have sinned genuinely repent and receive correction.
And help those doing the correcting walk in meekness, wisdom, truth, and love.
In Jesus Christ's name, Amen.
Scriptures for Further Study
- Matthew 18:15–17 - The process of confronting a brother
- Galatians 6:1 - Restore in the spirit of meekness
- Galatians 2:11–14 - Paul's correction of Peter
- 1 Timothy 5:19–20 - Accusations and correction concerning elders
- Deuteronomy 19:15 - Establishing a matter through witnesses
- Proverbs 18:13 - Hearing a matter before answering
- Proverbs 18:17 - Hearing more than one side
- Proverbs 11:13 - Gossip and revealing secrets
- Proverbs 15:1 - A soft answer
- Proverbs 24:17 - Do not rejoice when an enemy falls
- Ephesians 4:25–32 - Truth, anger, forgiveness, and speech
- Romans 13:1–4 - Civil authority and wrongdoing
- 1 John 4:1 - Try the spirits
- Titus 3:10–11 - Dealing with a divisive person
- 2 Thessalonians 3:14–15 - Correction without treating a believer as an enemy
About the Author
Avery Raquel
Avery Raquel is the founder of Avery Raquel Ministries and Disciples of Christ Ministries. Through Bible-based teachings, Scripture resources, prayer resources, books, and Christian music, her ministry seeks to encourage people to grow in their relationship with Jesus Christ and develop a deeper understanding of the Word of God.
Scripture quotations in this article are from the King James Version (KJV).